BALANCE, PLAY AND 'GAME-FEEL'
Posted: Sun Aug 28, 2011 9:37 am
Message from a big player to an offer (b4 raids) to cooexist etc...
Edit ~ Please avoid posting pm's ~ Cypher
Message seems to be: If I'm nasty enough people will stop playing and I can then farm them? Or 'It's a wargame, live with it'.
Sure I risk the accusation of being a 'whiner'. Still here's a few valid points (also brought up in other threads on this forum but with the wrong title to pull in all the debate on teh subject a good game engine deserves):
1. There is need for balance and 'game' and 'play' to make it a 'war-game', not just war.
2. If someone reaches ~1000 BCs & can then win against any mid-ranked player and all below with zero losses and then continue to keep them at zero (farming them) with zero losses and zero maintenance (as they continue to build toward infinity), I see a problem.
3. Good Gaming is all about balance. Do we have it? A combat engine that allows totally one sided combat losses (beyond a certain superiority) and the totally artificial and frankly boring FS (and the dueterium cost to maintain it) only required by the lower classed players.... and not effective anyway for irregular players. These are not very 'realistic' or fun game features.
4. Game Moderators/ Hosts will know what the player numbers are, % stayers and the average player life expectancy of new players, and possibly even the hours loggged-on to make it work for the ones who stay... I wonder if these are the numbers games hosts want? I suppose true devotees may be the ones using a trickle of rubies and the newbies not? But still...
Valid points to discuss methinks and I hope you agree. If it results in a few balancing tweaks to what is a great game engine, I'm pleased. Not a great 'game' yet though.
This is a potential epic wargame but currently an eddy besides the host of other serious contenders. My top 2 are Edit and Edit each having alot more to offer in terms of play, feel, balance and features. Sci-fi though does have a extra zest for me, and I'm keen to see Zorg succeed.
And other online browser based games ~ Cypher
?:-)
Edit ~ Please avoid posting pm's ~ Cypher
Message seems to be: If I'm nasty enough people will stop playing and I can then farm them? Or 'It's a wargame, live with it'.
Sure I risk the accusation of being a 'whiner'. Still here's a few valid points (also brought up in other threads on this forum but with the wrong title to pull in all the debate on teh subject a good game engine deserves):
1. There is need for balance and 'game' and 'play' to make it a 'war-game', not just war.
2. If someone reaches ~1000 BCs & can then win against any mid-ranked player and all below with zero losses and then continue to keep them at zero (farming them) with zero losses and zero maintenance (as they continue to build toward infinity), I see a problem.
3. Good Gaming is all about balance. Do we have it? A combat engine that allows totally one sided combat losses (beyond a certain superiority) and the totally artificial and frankly boring FS (and the dueterium cost to maintain it) only required by the lower classed players.... and not effective anyway for irregular players. These are not very 'realistic' or fun game features.
4. Game Moderators/ Hosts will know what the player numbers are, % stayers and the average player life expectancy of new players, and possibly even the hours loggged-on to make it work for the ones who stay... I wonder if these are the numbers games hosts want? I suppose true devotees may be the ones using a trickle of rubies and the newbies not? But still...
Valid points to discuss methinks and I hope you agree. If it results in a few balancing tweaks to what is a great game engine, I'm pleased. Not a great 'game' yet though.
This is a potential epic wargame but currently an eddy besides the host of other serious contenders. My top 2 are Edit and Edit each having alot more to offer in terms of play, feel, balance and features. Sci-fi though does have a extra zest for me, and I'm keen to see Zorg succeed.
And other online browser based games ~ Cypher
?:-)