Page 1 of 1

Ship Questions

Posted: Wed Feb 17, 2010 2:58 am
by TimeMor
I'm new to the finer points of the numbers here and am wondering on how the battleship fares against the destroyer. I’ve run the numbers in the simulator however I am assuming that this browser game is just like any other browser game when it comes to battles and not battles in the simulator. To that end here are some specifics and I’d like input on these figures from the veterans here.

My concern is if it is more cost effective to mass produce battleships rather than destroyers. Based on number crunching I have done and included below, it appears to me that battleships are the way to go.

From what I've seen based on the 1:2:4 ratios of resource production, where metal = 1, crystal = 2, and Deuterium = 4, and then adding up all the costs for the battleship and destroyer, and then converting to the lowest common denominator I get the following numbers:

22 battleships to 7 destroyers
Where 1 battleship = 70,000 resources
And where 1 destroyer = 220,000 resources

Please correct my any misconceptions I have and explain to me why in a simulated battle with 22 battleships against 7 destroyers (same relative resource cost), the destroyers do so badly.

Re: Ship Questions

Posted: Wed Feb 17, 2010 3:11 am
by Bouncer
well, some poeple use 3:2:1 ratio(bs still probably more effecient)

But what you are leaving out is speed, and more importantly, Deut costs to move.

Re: Ship Questions

Posted: Wed Feb 17, 2010 3:46 am
by Weresloth
Moved.

Re: Ship Questions

Posted: Wed Feb 17, 2010 12:02 pm
by dexternl
Destroyer
Resources Needed : Metal: 60.000 Crystal: 50.000 Deuterium: 15.000
Structure points 110.000
Shield Strength 500
Attack Points 2.000
Cargo Capacity 2.000 Units
Base Speed 5.000
Fuel Consumption (Deuterium) 1.000 (compared to BS fuel/speed = 2.000)

Battleship
Resources Needed : Metal: 50.000 Crystal: 10.000
Structure points 60.000
Shield Strength 200
Attack Points 1.000
Cargo Capacity 1.500 Units
Base Speed 10.000
Fuel Consumption (Deuterium) 500

3:2:1 -> metal
BS cost 165.000 Metal (181ships) = 29.865.000 Metal
DS cost 300.000 Metal (100ships) = 30.000.000 Metal

BATTLE:
100DS vs 181BS Sim at all 17 tech
64DS, 48DS, 56DS, 24DS, 57DS, 48DS, 34DS

Destroyers always wins.

STATS:
DS compared to BS
DS 4x expensive fuel wise per speed.
DS 2x the firepower
DS 2,5x shielding
DS 1,3x cargo
DS 1.81x more cost.

So the weak points for DS is fuel and cargo.
the rest is better cost wise.

But since the fuel and cargo is very important to raiding/fleeting, it isn't really that usefull.
Oh yea it has some RF vs Light Lasers.